I've just watched the BBC Four documentary Behind The Scenes At The Museum: The National Waterways Museum.
(It's available on BBC iPlayer until Thursday 10pm, and downloadable).
I'd never heard before of "acclaimed filmmaker" Richard Macer - who filmed, produced and directed it, which I guess means he was the only one on site, behind the camera as well as narrating - but it's hugely enjoyable.
The premise synopsis:
The National Waterways Museum at Ellesmere Port marks the birthplace of the industrial revolution when canals were built to transport goods to emerging cities like Liverpool and Manchester.
A financial crisis has left the museum with a reputation for sunken boats, and unless the situation improves dramatically some of the country's oldest barges and narrowboats might have to be sold off or even destroyed.
The museum's many volunteers are angry and believe its dire predicament is the result of mismanagement, so a new director is being brought on board with the task of saving it.
In just a short while Stuart Gillis makes a big impression and the staff and volunteers begin to see him as a saviour. But will Stuart be able to live up to such high expectations?
The Waterways Trust runs three National Waterways Museums - at Ellesmere (the biggest site), Gloucester Docks and the smaller Stoke Bruerne, and there's been talk that one or more of them could be closed down. Ultimately, Ellesmere is considered the kernel (and not just because it's got the most nuts!)
It's interesting to compare the announcement of the appointment of Gillis in February 2008...
The Waterways Trust is delighted to announce the appointment of Stuart Gillis as museum director.
As well as developing the strategic direction of the National Waterways Museum and Archives, Stuart will oversee the day-to-day management of the museums and be responsible for conserving the nationally important inland waterways collection
[their emphasis]
... and the lack of a press release announcing his departure late last year, shortly after he appointed his own day-to-day manager for the Ellesmere Port museum (a former cinema manager who begins his inspection by checking the loos.)
The Ellesmere Port museum is chiefly manned by volunteers, and they seemed to be in a ferment of discontent until Gillis came along.
He starts with a whirlwind of bold measures, including the on-camera statement that "Sometimes you do acknowledge that you have a graveyard and you allow some things to rot back into nature." (above, 29mins in.) That's probably an attitude that would have stopped Robert Aickman's heart.
He announced halfway through that the museum couldn't justify his high executive salary, that he'd resign, and that it made more sense to employ two less high-powered staff.
The motive appears to have been more cynical - that he'd quietly been offered the job of museums director for Derby City Council, and his gesture was dressed up in politics.
But Gillis does seem to have left the museums a success - at least for now. Not only with visitor numbers on the increase, but the 'heritage boatyard' he started is now operational and restoring some of those rotting boats.
It's a shame that The Waterways Trust itself doesn't acknowledge his contribution. The only mention of him on the website is accidentally in the list of the Trust's directors - which is almost a year out of date.
In fact, you'd never have known what he did, was it not for the documentary. He's been airbrushed out. Why do PR people always do that?
The film is stuffed full of amusing and sensitive vignettes. For example, one of the volunteers, Paul, is clearly held in very low regard by another.
There's a hilarious point (13mins in) where Paul says an engine is two-stroke and that 'Lee' in the background has removed a component.
But behind him 'Lee' silently shakes his head to indicate that that's bullshit, then holds up four fingers to point out it's a four-stroke, and mumbles through a sandwich that his name is actually Phil.
The whole tenor of the documentary is that the National Waterways Museum is "the last hope of these listing vessels." And yet...
And yet...
I've argued and will still argue, that the real 'national waterways museum' is the whole canal system itself, which has changed little in 60 years, at least in the way it works.
Boat, cycle or walk the canals (even fish them) with a canal guide, and you can learn more history than in any museum. It might take longer, but there's a greater sense of history and place.
And as for boats, well, there's a huge amount of preservation and development that goes on privately.
You only have to follow Sarah's Chertsey blog to see that. She bought an old 1930s GUCCC Woolwich motor narrowboat privately, and is doing more to restore it and at a faster rate than any volunteer at the museum. You can learn an awful lot of canal-boat history from her.
And when it's finished, it'll be a real boat, not a museum exhibit. She's a one-man wonder-woman waterways museum herself.
Although, granted, if you visit Chertsey at its boatyard in Stretton her ice cream, postcard and souvenir selection is somewhat limited.
Recent Comments